The Politics of Military Force

The Politics of Military Force examines the dynamics of discursive change that made participation in military operations possible against the background of German antimilitarist culture. Once considered a strict taboo, so-called out-of-area operations have now become widely considered by German policymakers to be without alternative. The book argues that an understanding of how certain policies are made possible (in this case, military operations abroad and force transformation), one needs to focus on processes of discursive change that result in different policy options appearing rational, appropriate, feasible, or even self-evident. Drawing on Essex School discourse theory, the book develops a theoretical framework to understand how discursive change works, and elaborates on how discursive change makes once unthinkable policy options not only acceptable but even without alternative. Based on a detailed discourse analysis of more than 25 years of German parliamentary debates, The Politics of Military Force provides an explanation for: (1) the emergence of a new hegemonic discourse in German security policy after the end of the Cold War (discursive change), (2) the rearticulation of German antimilitarism in the process (ideational change/norm erosion) and (3) the resulting making-possible of military operations and force transformation (policy change). In doing so, the book also demonstrates the added value of a poststructuralist approach compared to the naive realism and linear conceptions of norm change so prominent in the study of German foreign policy and International Relations more generally.

Read the free introduction or browse the book on Google Books

(30% off with promotion code UMSTENGEL at Michigan UP)

Also available on Barnes&Noble and Rakuten Kobo.

PRAISE

“The Politics of Military Force offers a persuasive and novel analysis of a fascinating phenomenon: that Germany simultaneously embraces both antimilitarism and military interventions. The book does much more, however. It develops a sphisticated approach to analyzing discursive and policy change relevant much beyond the case of Germany.”

Maja Zehfuss, Professor of International Politics, University of Manchester

“In this path-breaking and carefully argued book, Frank Stengel uses the resources of poststructuralist discourse theory to provide a compelling critical explanation of the transformation of Germany’s security policy over the last thirty years. Engaging thoroughly with existing theoretical and empirical debates in foreign policy analysis and International Relations, the book is an exemplary employment of new ideas to problematize pressing problems and issues. The Politics of Military Force will surely come to function as a paradigmatic study that will stimulate further empirical investigation and theoretical reflection.”

David Howarth, Professor, Department of Government, University of Essex

The Politics of Military Force offers a theory of foreign policy that shifts the focus toward the ontological analysis of society in a sophisticated and and innovative manner. I can think of no other book that has gone as far as Stengel’s in the explanation of discursive change in foreign policy and international politics.”

Dirk Nabers, Professor of International Political Sociology, Kiel University

“The committee truly enjoyed reading this dissertation in particular, and found it to be very impressive and ground-breaking in terms of theory, approach, and research. Indeed, it is a truly remarkable work in terms of significance and originality. The use of poststructural discourse analysis in a highly operationalized and innovative way to examine over 25 years of archival documents for German parliamentary debates impressed the committee. This account of how and why German policy-makers changed from being antimilitarist to willing to support military operations even outside of Europe was highly compelling.”

Award Committee, EISA Best Dissertation Award 2018, European International Studies Association

REVIEWS

“Stengel’s greatest contribution is the demonstration that security policy discourse has had both an enabling as well as a limiting effect on Germany’s use of force, leading to Germany’s regular participation in foreign military missions, but with restrictions that often seem incomprehensible to Germany’s allies. This insight has implications for the importance of language and ideational creation, not only in the local German environment but also within the broader of context of transatlantic security as well.”

Joseph Verbovszky on Atlantic Community

“Stengel argues convincingly that the changes in German security discourse and practice are not inevitable adjustments to any functional requirements of a changing security environment. … Stengel’s book contributes to a growing body of literature that—correctly in my view—treats security policy change not as inevitable adjustments to a country’s changing environment, but as the result of political decisions that reflect value commitments, worldviews, and the expectations of the domestic public as well as allied states. Stengel’s contribution is theoretically sophisticated and empirically rich.

Wolfgang Wagner in Perspectives on Politics

TABLE OF CONTENTS

Introduction (open access)

Chapter 1. Hegemony and Social Transformation: How Discursive Orders Change

Chapter 2. Hegemony Analysis as Reconstructive Social Research: Methodology and Methods

Chapter 3. Creative Destruction: The Dislocation of the Cold War Security Order and the Rearticulation of Military Force

Chapter 4. Peace in Europe: Comprehensive Security as a New Paradigm for German Policy on Conflict Prevention

Chapter 5. “Forward Defense” as a New Grand Strategy: The Establishment of the New Security Order

Conclusion